Welcome to Lorelei Restaurant & Cabana Bar, a hidden jewel nestled along the stunning waterfront of Islamorada, Florida. Positioned at 96 Madeira Rd, this enchanting dining spot promises not just a meal, but an experience steeped in delightful flavors and mesmerizing views. As you step into Lorelei, it’s hard not to be captivated by the idyllic island atmosphere that feels like the essence of the Keys.

The reviews speak volumes about the charm of Lorelei. With every table offering a breathtaking view of the water, diners are treated to a visual feast that complements the delicious food and signature drinks on offer. Patrons like Butt Wheat emphasize the friendliness of the service and the quality of the meals, asserting that Lorelei is not just an off-the-beaten-path stop, but a destination in itself.

As you immerse yourself in the beautiful setting, you can gorge on dishes like the blackened snapper or the widely praised coconut shrimp, which have left many guests—including Kristina Cook—raving about their culinary experiences. The burger and fries are equally compelling, receiving applause for their richness and flavor, though some diners like prohomevideos have noted room for improvement in certain offerings, such as the fish tacos. However, the overall ambiance and welcoming staff, like Amy and Chris, add to the dining delight that many have come to cherish.

The sunset views at Lorelei are genuinely something magical. Adrienne Jezick encourages fellow diners to plan their visit around this golden hour, ensuring an experience buttressed by live music and the warm glow of twilight. It renders a perfect backdrop to any gathering—be it a casual dinner or a significant reunion, like Joyce Davis Meeks’ nostalgic meeting with old classmates.

Amongst the delightful offerings, the lobster special with mango salsa stands out, adding a tropical twist that evokes the region’s vibrant culture. The macaroni and cheese, while critiqued for simplicity, can be elevated with additional toppings, allowing guests to customize their satisfaction. Lorelei is not about fine dining but about indulging in delicious food in a fun, casual setting—one that feels straight out of a Jimmy Buffet song, as quilski aptly noted.

In essence, Lorelei Restaurant & Cabana Bar is more than just a restaurant; it's a culinary haven that perfectly encapsulates the spirit of the Florida Keys. For anyone making their way towards Key West or simply seeking an unforgettable dining experience, Lorelei stands as a culinary beacon where the food is tasty, the drinks refreshing, and the views simply spectacular.

For reservations or inquiries, feel free to reach out at +1 305-664-2692. Come savor the flavors of paradise!